Vinyl vs. Wood Fencing: Which Is Right for Your Home?

When it comes to enhancing the privacy, curb appeal, and security of your property, few investments are as impactful as a well-built fence. If you're a homeowner in Smithfield, Rhode Island—or anywhere across Providence County—you may be weighing the pros and cons of vinyl fencing vs. wood fencing. At A. Belmonte & Son, we've been helping Rhode Island residents make the right choice for decades, offering expert fence installation backed by a 5-year labor warranty.


In this blog, we’ll break down the key differences between vinyl and wood fencing so you can decide which is best suited for your home, budget, and lifestyle.


The Importance of Choosing the Right Fence in Rhode Island

Whether you’re looking to enclose your backyard in Greenville, protect your garden in Lincoln, or add curb appeal to a home near Bryant University, the New England climate can be a challenge. With icy winters, humid summers, and Nor’easter storms, Rhode Island fences need to withstand serious weather fluctuations.



This makes choosing the right fencing material more than just a style decision—it’s about durability, maintenance, and long-term value.


Vinyl Fencing: Low-Maintenance, Modern, and Durable

Pros of Vinyl Fencing

1. Weather Resistance: Vinyl fences are virtually immune to the effects of Rhode Island weather. They won’t warp, rot, or fade under pressure from rain, snow, or UV exposure—making them a top choice for properties near Slacks Reservoir or Georgiaville Pond, where moisture levels are often high.

2. Minimal Maintenance: Vinyl fencing is incredibly low-maintenance. A quick hose-down is usually enough to keep it looking clean, making it ideal for busy homeowners who don’t want to spend weekends sanding or staining wood.

3. Longevity: Vinyl fencing can last 20–30 years or more with proper installation. At A. Belmonte & Son, we install premium-grade vinyl panels that resist cracking, splitting, and discoloration.

4. Aesthetic Options: Modern vinyl comes in various colors and styles—from classic white pickets to privacy fences that mimic the look of wood grain. You get the charm of wood without the upkeep.


Cons of Vinyl Fencing

Higher Upfront Cost: Vinyl fencing can be more expensive to install initially than wood. However, lower maintenance costs often balance this out over time.

Less Natural Look: While today’s vinyl mimics wood quite well, some homeowners still prefer the authentic warmth and rustic charm of real lumber.

Wood Fencing: Classic, Customizable, and Eco-Friendly

Pros of Wood Fencing

1. Timeless Aesthetics: There’s something uniquely charming about a wood fence. Whether you're aiming for a Cape Cod feel or a rustic New England homestead vibe, wood offers unmatched natural beauty.

2. Customization Options: Wood fences are easy to cut, stain, and paint, allowing homeowners near Deerfield Park or Downtown Providence to match their fence to their home’s color palette or landscaping.

3. Environmentally Friendly: Wood is a renewable resource, especially when sourced sustainably. Many homeowners value its lower environmental footprint compared to manufactured materials.

4. Initial Affordability: Wood fencing often has a lower upfront cost than vinyl, making it a popular choice for budget-conscious property owners.


Cons of Wood Fencing

  • High Maintenance: Wood fences need regular sealing, staining, or painting to prevent rot, insect damage, and warping—especially in Rhode Island’s fluctuating climate.
  • Shorter Lifespan: Even with diligent maintenance, wood fences typically last 10–15 years, especially in coastal or damp areas like Narragansett Bay or Pawtucket.
  • Susceptible to Weather Damage: New England winters can be rough on wood. Snow buildup and freezing temperatures can cause boards to split or warp over time.


Which Fence Is Right for You?

Choose Vinyl If:

  • You want low maintenance and long-lasting durability.
  • You live in an area with high moisture or extreme seasonal changes.
  • You prefer a modern look with clean lines.
  • You plan to stay in your home long-term and want a cost-effective investment.

Choose Wood If:

  • You love the classic, natural look of real wood.
  • You’re comfortable with seasonal maintenance.
  • You’re looking for an affordable upfront cost.
  • You want to customize the color, shape, or height.


Why Trust A. Belmonte & Son for Your Fence Installation?

As a family-owned company based right here in Smithfield, we understand the unique needs of Rhode Island homeowners. From North Scituate to Cranston, we've installed thousands of fences with care, craftsmanship, and community pride.


Every installation we perform is backed by a 5-year labor warranty, and our experienced team ensures your fence is built to last through whatever the New England weather throws your way.


Get a Free Fence Estimate Today

Still unsure which fence is best for your property? Contact A. Belmonte & Son today for a free on-site estimate. We’ll help you choose the right materials, style, and budget-friendly options tailored to your needs.